NOTE: we had some audio problems during the basic critiques, so there are multiple places where the audio is muted. The problems consisted of feedback and microphones not muted.

The chat window is here: chat_230105.txt

This is our annual "oldies" competition. Unlike our other competitions, this competition requires that the submitted images be at least two years old unless you really don't have any photos that old (e.g. beginning photographers).

The judges were:

• Basic and Intermediate levels: Mark Laussade, Charles Schwartz, Nick Grossman
• Advanced level judge: Jerry Schlesinger (from PSA)

Larger, more detailed versions of the winning photos can be seen on napfs.org at "Competitions > Past Competition Winners > Competition Winners for 2023"